“Avatar”: Beautiful but Silly

James Cameron may have created the most beautiful movie to date in “Avatar.” More than $400,000,000 later- it’s breathtaking. Just a week ago I saw it in the theater. While the visual grandeur captivated us moment by moment, the message of the story ended up being silly. Avatar is an excellent example of what a big Hollywood budget can do artistically- while promoting ideas that are far from true.
Good art has both an aesthetic element and a truth element.
Creativity can be used to express truth or lies. It’s always important to consider wether a work of art syncs with reality or promotes confusion. Even though beauty sometimes leads to truth, it can also be used to seduce as the song of the sirens did in Homer’s Odyssey.
Avatar rightly shows that an amazing creation (like the fanciful Pandora or a blockbuster movie) owes it’s existence to something beyond itself, the whole “life force” thing is kind of hokie. While watching the movie I couldn’t help wonder if the “all mother” tree goddess really was transcendent why didn’t she warn the Na’vi about the intruding enemy’s schemes? A supernatural being that’s supposedly the foundation of life would have wisdom to see something like that happening wouldn’t they? And the topic of misleading ideas brings us to the the concept of avatar- which technically means “incarnation” in some languages. The incarnations in this movie, make no mistake about it, have evil intentions from the beginning. The “gods” were out to steal. This couldn’t be further from the message of a God who loves the world so much that he gives up everything precious to enter and rescue it from self-destruction. Avatar’s spirituality message, if true, would make people want to run rather than feel in any way safe.
While the beauty of the movie makes us feel good, it leads the viewer to feel good about the wrong things. Visually Avatar is a marvel but ideologically, it’s a mess. Like cotton candy, Avatar is a momentary thrill with the potential to make a person sick.
Thumbs up to Avatar’s designers! You’re my heroes, but the next time someone seeks to spend that much money on art they can do the audience good by making it’s message correspond to reality.





